Incident library · Postal and retail services · United Kingdom

    Post Office Limited: Subpostmasters wrongly held liable for shortfalls

    Subpostmasters were held liable for shortfalls in their branch accounts that the Post Office's Horizon system had recorded.
    High Court of England and WalesDec 2019

    Bates and Others v Post Office Limited: Judgment (No.6) Horizon Issues

    Subpostmasters wrongly held liable for shortfalls

    Found by the court

    The High Court found the Horizon accounting system had high levels of bugs, errors and defects, and was capable of creating shortfalls in branch accounts.

    Found by the court

    The reported contributing factor

    The High Court found the Horizon accounting system had high levels of bugs, errors and defects, and was capable of creating shortfalls in branch accounts.

    Incidents usually have several contributing factors. This is the one public reporting names; it is not presented as the sole cause.

    Which StackUp assessment checks for this gap

    Find out if your organisation has this gap

    Sources

    Published Dec 2019. Sources last checked Nov 2026. Spotted an error or an update? Tell us and we will correct it.

    • Information Age (ACS)Aug 2024

      ASIC sues ASX over failed blockchain project

      About $250 million written off

      Alleged by the regulator

      The regulator alleges the ASX told the market the project was on track when it had no reasonable basis to say so.

    • Local Government LawyerFeb 2025

      Auditors highlight poor oversight and reporting at city council over troubled IT programme

      Costs grew from £19 million to over £100 million

      Identified in an independent review

      External auditors found oversight of the programme was absent or ineffective, and that bad news was not welcome.

    • The Irish TimesOct 2022

      Former Uber security chief is convicted of covering up data breach and paying off hackers

      Former security chief convicted

      Found by the court

      The breach was kept from regulators instead of being disclosed, a jury found.

    Find out which of these gaps you have

    The free Readiness Check takes ten questions and shows the incidents tied to your weakest answers.