Incident library · Legal services · Australia

    A Melbourne law practice: Lost the right to practise as a principal

    A solicitor filed documents in a family court case that cited cases which did not exist. The hearing was adjourned and the lawyer was referred to the regulator.
    Information Age (ACS)Sep 2025

    First Australian lawyer penalised for AI blunder

    Lost the right to practise as a principal

    Found by the regulator

    AI-generated case citations were filed in court without anyone checking they were real.

    Found by the regulator

    The reported contributing factor

    AI-generated case citations were filed in court without anyone checking they were real.

    Incidents usually have several contributing factors. This is the one public reporting names; it is not presented as the sole cause.

    Which StackUp assessment checks for this gap

    Find out if your organisation has this gap

    Sources

    Published Sep 2025. Sources last checked Nov 2026. Spotted an error or an update? Tell us and we will correct it.

    • LawSitesJun 2023

      Court Imposes Sanctions On Lawyers Who Filed Bogus Cases After Relying On ChatGPT For Legal Research

      $5,000 sanction and public censure

      Found by the court

      Cases suggested by ChatGPT were filed without anyone checking they were real, and the lawyers stood by them when questioned, the court found.

    • Information Age (ACS)Oct 2025

      Deloitte to refund government over AI errors

      Partial refund on a $440,000 contract

      Reported contributing factor

      A report drafted with generative AI included references that did not exist and was not checked before delivery.

    • OVICSep 2024

      Investigation into the use of ChatGPT by a Child Protection worker

      Generative AI tools blocked across the department

      Found by the regulator

      Sensitive case details were entered into a public AI tool, and the department had not put adequate controls or training in place.

    Find out which of these gaps you have

    The free Readiness Check takes ten questions and shows the incidents tied to your weakest answers.